The supply chain warning is not the decision
At an American automaker, the question of how many wiper blades had been sold once produced different answers depending on which system was consulted. The company supports 1.4 million spare-part SKUs, serves 12,000 dealers and maintains parts for vehicles dating back to 1938. Forecasting, warehousing and inventory management had developed separately, with spreadsheets holding parts of the operation together. Before planners could decide what to stock, they had to establish which number to believe.
The automaker has since unified key planning activities, but accurate data alone cannot tell a factory what to do when a component becomes unavailable. For Salman Adil, manufacturing industry principal at Kinaxis, a global provider of supply chain planning and orchestration software, the harder challenge is weighing possible responses before the window to protect production closes.
“Visibility is essential, and that’s where people have invested,” Adil says. “But it’s a foundation. In manufacturing, it’s not just about the alert. If a component is late, you really need to know which production lines are going to be impacted. Which customer orders? How is your cost going to be impacted? And then, most importantly, what are your alternatives?”
A late delivery creates more than a material shortage
Suppose a critical supplier confirms that a component will arrive two weeks late. Purchasing can flag the exception immediately, but the part may be used in several products, and available stock may already be committed. Moving production to another line could displace orders equally important to the business.
A two-week supplier delay might look manageable to procurement but threaten a major customer commitment that production cannot easily recover. Both departments may be working with accurate information, yet reach very different conclusions because neither has the complete picture. “The intelligence kicks in by enabling you to understand the consequence of a decision before you commit to it,” Adil explains. “That way, you go in with a wide-angle view and really understand the broader business impact. You manage the supply chain as an interconnected system, not just individual activities.”
A substitute component might keep one order on time but destroy its margin. Delaying delivery may protect profit while damaging a valuable customer relationship. An accurate picture of the factory’s options cannot make that commercial judgment for the manufacturer.
One set of numbers, several competing priorities
Agreeing on a shared forecast forces questions that separate departments could previously avoid. Whose customer should take the delay, how much extra cost is acceptable and what happens to inventory when priorities shift? Concurrent planning can make those consequences visible across the business, but leaders still must choose between them.
“Procurement might be optimizing their buys and their cost picture,” Adil says. “Sales, of course, is focusing specifically on the revenue side, and manufacturing wants to optimize capacity. But bringing everyone to the table and having that shared view of trade-offs changes the game. It’s an opportunity to manage the supply chain, not just manage within the supply chain.”
The automaker in questions has implemented sales and operations planning, inventory optimization and supply constraints in Kinaxis Maestro, replacing much of the reconciliation between separate systems. Its planners can assess how demand changes affect warehouse capacity, product mix and financial performance using shared information. Demand planning and distribution requirements planning were still to follow when its case study was published, so the transformation remains incomplete.
Testing the consequences before the schedule changes
Once the competing priorities are visible, planning becomes an exercise in comparing possible futures. An alternative supplier may save a production run but reduce margin. Moving work between plants can preserve customer service while increasing transport and setup costs. Those decisions need to be judged against the objectives of the business, not simply whether a revised schedule can be produced faster.
The strongest scenario tools expose the measures behind a recommendation, rather than present one answer as inevitable. Planners still must decide whether the proposed compromise is acceptable to the people responsible for production and customer relationships. “We have scorecards that allow you to see the impact of a scenario against the KPIs that are important to you,” Adil explains. “For a business, those typically include service, profitability, inventory and asset utilization, not just one functional KPI.”
Konica Minolta demonstrates what that capability looks like under pressure. Its planning process moved from weekly to daily calculations, providing a more current view of production, sales and inventory. During the pandemic, the company used simulations to examine the consequences of factory shutdowns in China, disrupted shipping and changing sales expectations. The purpose was not to predict precisely when the disruption would end, but to identify which responses remained viable as conditions changed.
A scenario cannot eliminate a shortage, but it can prevent valuable time being lost debating its implications while conditions deteriorate. That was the benefit Konica Minolta reported when the organization needed to respond to successive disruptions rather than rely on its previous planning cycle. “As we were able to accurately simulate business risks, we were able to rapidly investigate and implement the actions we needed to take,” says Mamoru Ohara, a supply chain planning leader at Konica Minolta.
A plan only has value when somebody can execute it
Even an agreed response can unravel when the planning system stops at the boundary of the factory. Revised priorities must become production instructions; purchasing requirements may change, suppliers need to be contacted and customer commitments must be checked. If those steps remain dependent on emails or disconnected applications, the time saved in scenario analysis may disappear before the first schedule is updated.
Veolia’s water technology business is tackling precisely this gap through a phased effort to connect sales forecasting, supply planning and production scheduling. Starting with demand planning for its ZeeWeed membrane products, the company is developing a broader process intended to link Kinaxis Maestro with manufacturing execution through PlanetTogether, a specialist provider of advanced production planning and scheduling software. The rollout is ongoing, and its significance is the work needed to align departments and operating practices, rather than a finished claim of end-to-end automation.
A bidirectional connection also tests whether the planning model reflects what the plant can achieve. A schedule that looks feasible before the shift starts may need revising when output falls or a line is unavailable. Planners need reliable feedback from production before they can make a promise that the factory can keep.
As planning becomes more continuous, the sheer volume of exceptions threatens to consume the time needed for those judgments. Kinaxis customers are already using AI agents to investigate supply disruptions, although their use does not transfer responsibility for customer and production commitments to software. “Agents help planners take on investigative work they do manually today, and that takes a lot of time,” Adil explains. “They can monitor exceptions, pull relevant context and help test options. The key is surfacing the recommendation. Planners can then spend less time working through all these possibilities and more time applying judgment to the most relevant option.”
The longer-term change may be to what a planner does each morning, rather than simply the speed of a calculation. “Agents can work for you in parallel,” Adil says. “They can work for you before you show up and ask, ‘What are my options?’ They can have that prepared. That changes the role of the planner into an orchestrator, a better decision maker, rather than someone who must pore through data and laborious analysis.”
Ecolab, a global provider of water, hygiene and infection prevention solutions, took a carefully managed approach to introducing Kinaxis Maestro. The company ran systems in parallel, began with a pilot covering just 22 of approximately 30,000 SKUs, undertook extensive user training and rehearsed the cutover before full deployment. For Andrew Strobe, Ecolab’s director of supply chain and global advance planning program leader, protecting existing customer commitments was the overriding priority. “The most important thing was zero disruption for our customers,” Strobe says.
Ecolab subsequently reported roughly 10 percent lower inventory, five percent higher productivity and no unplanned system downtime, according to the Kinaxis customer study. The gains followed extensive preparation, rather than relying solely on better software. They also depended on protecting the customers whose orders could not wait for a transformation project.
Ecolab’s careful rollout also demonstrates that better planning is not simply a question of faster calculations. The automaker needed a reliable view of demand, Konica Minolta gained the ability to evaluate disruption scenarios more frequently, and Veolia is working to connect planning decisions directly with production schedules. Ecolab adds the essential test of whether those improvements can be introduced without disrupting customers. Together, these examples show what decision intelligence must ultimately deliver: not more warnings or increasingly sophisticated forecasts, but informed decisions that manufacturers can act upon while there is still time to protect production and customer commitments.

